80 PINE STREET, 33RD FLOOR, NEW YORK, NY 10005   |   (212) 509-1616
BLOG

Beranbaum Menken Files Landmark Infertility Treatment Coverage Lawsuit on Behalf of New Jersey Women in Same-Sex Relationships

New Jersey law requires insurance companies to extend coverage for medically-indicated infertility treatment to women who qualify as infertile under what is referred to as the New Jersey Infertility Mandate. Despite the existence of myriad diagnostic tools and techniques by which a fertility specialist may diagnose infertility independent of heterosexual intercourse, a woman may only qualify as “infertile” under the Mandate after engaging in unprotected sex with a male partner for 1 or 2 years, depending on her age, and failing to conceive. As a result, New Jersey women with female partners are often forced to pay tens of thousands of dollars out of pocket to treat their infertility in the hope of one day becoming mothers.

As reported by the New York Times, last week Beranbaum Menken filed Krupa et al. v. Badolato in the United States District Court for the District of New Jersey, aimed at forcing New Jersey to expand the protection of the Mandate to all women struggling with clinical infertility in the State. As stated in the Complaint:

This civil rights case is about family and the right of all New Jersey women who dream of becoming mothers to access the reproductive healthcare they need to realize that dream on an equal basis, regardless of their sexual orientation. “Rising from the most basic human needs,” parenthood “is essential to our most profound hopes and aspirations,” just like marriage. Obergefell v. Hodges, 135 S. Ct. 2584, 2594 (2015). In fact, as quoted by Justice Anthony Kennedy in Obergefell, Cicero wrote: “The first bond of society is marriage; next, children; and then the family.” Id. (citing De Officiis 57 (W. Miller transl. 1913)). Now, as presaged by Kennedy as he extended Cicero’s first bond of society to all American same-sex couples in Obergefell, that decision also compels states like New Jersey to treat heterosexual and same-sex couples equally with respect to Cicero’s remaining bonds of society, as well. In order to protect all women who wish to have children and start families on equal footing, as required by the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution, because, like marriage, procreation is a fundamental right protected by the Due Process Clause of the same Amendment, and because 42 U.S.C. § 1983 prohibits the deprivation of Plaintiffs’ federal constitutional and statutory rights, New Jersey must extend the protections of its infertility insurance mandate to women in same-sex relationships.

This case will surely explore the ramifications of the Supreme Court’s landmark decision in Obergefell.

Additional media coverage from ABC Channel 7 and CBS 2 News.